I mentioned the other day how at the Maker Faire they had a demonstration on how to make a MetroCard holder, but it was really more an infomercial for a set of tools (large punch, adhesive machine, laminator, etc). However I liked the idea and new it could be done with things I had in my apartment. Well this week my old holder, which I had gotten for free at this arts festival from the Whitney Museum booth approximately 3 years ago, completely came apart.
How to make your own MetroCard* holder
Supplies: Scissors, clear tape, notecard, and MetroCard to determine size. I also used my old holder as a pattern, but it isn't necessary.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5da22/5da2237aeba04f458dd4f571eb86d709fc446b85" alt=""
You can use a piece of card stock or a post card as well.
Cut your paper to the appropriate height and fold in thirds. I made one flap a lot bigger than the other so that the grab hole (I just made that term up) wouldn't be on the two sides.
Then trace and cut out your grab hole
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2450f/2450f22cb9f5af91637973065f3b93c83e1d82f2" alt=""
Then I just used clear tape to tape the sides together and put a piece across the bottom. If you have clear packing tape it might be a good idea to just cover the whole thing to protect it a little.
front
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3d64c/3d64c6391ea313b6dceab64c436fc9fef030bf3e" alt=""
back
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/53582/5358276d07c58bdeec85abad27cfc8a7105e1acc" alt=""
my MetroCard ready to go
*Same process can be used to hold any type of card